View from the Mirador Punta Sur, Isla Mujeres, Mexico

Isla Mujeres Day Trip or Staying Overnight: Which Is Better?

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, which earn me a small commission from bookings at no extra cost to you. Thank you for reading and supporting my blog!

Share

There’s nothing wrong with only spending a few hours in a place. I’ve done plenty of cruises and been happy with the brief stops that allow me to get a taste of multiple destinations at the same time. However, it pales in comparison to the depth of the experience you get when you spend a night or two.

Isla Mujeres is close enough to Cancun that a lot of people treat it as a day trip. You hop on a ferry in the morning, drive a golf cart around the island, and you’re back at your resort by dinner.

You can absolutely do that or even take a catamaran tour over. We spent about a week in Mexico, with two of our nights in Isla Mujeres, and I would say it was one of the highlights of our trip.

Even though it’s touristy, Isla Mujeres is super different from Cancun and the all-inclusives there, so I’d tell most people to stay at least one night to experience it. Here’s how staying overnight compares to the day trip and how to decide what’s right for your trip.

The short answer: A day trip by ferry works if you just want to see the island. A sailing tour is perfect if you mainly want to spend time on the water. If you want to experience both the land and sea, soak up the local culture, and have time to relax under a palm tree, then stay overnight.

Day trip vs. Overnight

Day Trip by FerryStaying Overnight
Time on the islandAbout 6–8 hours, depending on your ferry timesOne or more full days, plus evenings
Whale shark tour (June–September)Possible from Cancun, but with an early start and a longer boat rideEasy with an island-based operator, a later wake-up call and a head start on the Cancun boats
Snorkeling & DivingHard to fit in unless you’re on a tourEasy to dedicate a half day
Golf cart loopA few hours, often rushed, or omitted for beach time. Take your time, stop at cafes and fruit stands
Sunset and dinner in CentroYou’ll likely miss it to catch a ferryLots of great restaurants and epic sunset from Playa Norte.
Packing and logisticsJust a day bagLuggage on the ferry (dedicated place onboard)
CostFerry, golf cart and activitiesAdd a hotel; budget and boutique options available
Best forShort Cancun trips and a quick lookWhale sharks, divers and anyone who wants to slow down
Outdoor seating on the Xcaret Xailing ferry
Outdoor seating on the Xcaret Xailing ferry

Isla Mujeres Day Trip

When you only have a few hours on the island, you really have to prioritize what’s the most important to you. For some it’s maximizing their time at the beach while for others it’s seeing the town. There are lots of things to do on Isla Mujeres, but I’d say what you can fit comfortably in a day would be some time at Playa Norte, some shopping and lunch in Centro, and a quick two hour golf cart ride around the island to see Punta Sur.

The golf cart ride is kinda pushing it, but may make more sense if you choose to relax at a beach club like Kin Ha or do snorkeling and zip lining at Garrafon Park instead of spending time at Playa Norte.

Either way, you’re off to an early start. Here’s a sample itinerary so you can get an idea of what your day could look like on a day trip to Isla Mujeres.

  1. Morning ferry: Ultramar leaves Puerto Juárez as early as 5:30 am, and Xailing’s first ferry from the Hotel Zone is at 9 am. See my Cancun to Isla Mujeres ferry guide to pick a pier.
  2. Morning at Playa Norte: The most famous beach in Isla Mujeres. The soft sand and calm waters are the great way to start your day. Grab a spot in the sand or rent a chair from one of the beach clubs or hotels.
  3. Lunch and shopping in Centro: There are plenty of great restaurants and food trucks to choose from for lunch. Shops run all down Avenida Miguel Hidalgo, making it easy to spend the whole afternoon here.
  4. Golf cart loop: Negotiate a good rate for a golf cart for a few hours. Drive around the island, stopping at Punta Sur for stunning clifftop views.
  5. Ferry back: Xailing’s last ferry leaves Isla Mujeres at 8 pm. Check times before you go, and note there’s no 3 pm Xailing departure.

Rather skip the logistics? Book a tour from Cancun

If you’d rather not deal with ferry schedules, taxis to the pier, and figuring out lunch, a tour from Cancun handles it all. Most combine the boat ride, snorkeling, food and drinks, and some free time on the island. You’ll pay more than the ferry and have less time to explore on your own, but it’s an easy way to spend a day on the water.

Skip the logistics

Isla Mujeres tours from Cancun

No worries or ferry schedules. These tours handle the boat, food and drinks so you can just enjoy the water.

Best all-inclusive day
Isla Mujeres luxury sailing
A 5.5-hour sail with snorkeling, lunch onboard, an open bar and free time on the island. Pick an adults-only or family-friendly boat. From about $55.
Check dates
Best bucket-list day
Whale shark adventure
Swim with whale sharks (in season), with hotel pickup in Cancun or the Riviera Maya, lunch and drinks, and no more than 10 people per boat. From about $155.
Check dates

Prices are starting rates and change by date. This box contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Prices are starting rates at the time of writing and change by date and option.

Catamaran and sailing tours

Stay in vacation mode with a tour that make it easy to step out of your hotel and be whisked away to the island. This is the easiest way to see Isla Mujeres if you mainly want a fun day on the water.

This luxury sailing tour lets you pick an adults-only boat or a smaller family-friendly one. Once you get to Isla Mujeres you’ll get change to snorkel and have lunch on the boat before being dropped off in town. The included lunch is described by one guest as “a bento box with a chicken wrap, a pasta salad, fruit, guacamole and chips,” which was sufficient, but the best part is that they keep the open bar drinks flowing.

Contact the tour company for hotel transportation, and negotiate a golf cart rental once you arrive on the island during your free time. There is a dock fee that is charged separately. This is much better than other sailing tours that pressure you into overpriced golf cart tours and make you rush through activities, only to waste time at a rundown beach club.

Natalie getting ready to jump off the boat to swim with the whale sharks in Mexico
Getting ready to jump off the boat to swim with the whale sharks.

Whale shark tours from Cancun

If you’re staying in Cancun or the Riviera Maya, you can still swim with whale sharks without spending a night on the island. It’s truly a bucket list experience that you shouldn’t miss if you’re in Cancun during the summer, which is whale shark season. This tour picks you up at your hotel and caps groups at 10 people.

A few things to know:

  • Expect an earlier start and a longer ride than an island-based tour. That’s the main reason we booked with an operator on Isla Mujeres.
  • Budget for extras. GoPro videos cost extra, and there’s a $10 cash environmental and dock fee per person. On our island-based tour, the GoPro video was free.
  • Take precautions if you get seasick easily. Many people were happy they took anti-nausea medication, the waves can be rough out there!

Want to compare? Read my whale shark tour review to see what booking from the island was like. We had a fantastic time on our whale shark swim and went to a sandbar afterward to unwind.

Festival celebrating the founding of Isla Mujeres
Festival celebrating the founding of Isla Mujeres with festivities in the main town square

Staying overnight in Isla Mujeres

Isla Mujeres is a little island that packs a big punch. With multiple beaches and snorkel spots to explore, tons of great restaurants, and boutique hotels that make you never want to leave, Isla Mujeres merits a couple days! We spent two nights there, and the notes below give you a good idea of what we covered. For all the details, refer to my 3 day itinerary for Isla Mujeres to make sure you fit in all the best things to do.

Day 1: Arrive and settle in

Day 2: Whale sharks (June–September) or snorkel/dive tour

  • Meet at the dive shop around 7:30 am for a whale shark tour with an island-based operator. Alternatively, take a snorkel or dive tour.
  • Swim with the whale sharks, then stop at a sandbar for fresh ceviche on the way back.
  • Spend a relaxed afternoon at the pool or on the beach, then have dinner in Centro.

Day 3: Golf cart loop and the ferry back

  • Rent a golf cart for the morning: fruit stands, Punta Sur, and the viewpoints along the way.
  • Catch an afternoon ferry back to Cancun.
In a rush?

My Isla Mujeres favorites

Short on time? These are the places I’d book, from where I stayed to the hidden gems outside the center.

Best beachfront boutique
Lotus Beach Hotel
On the sand steps from Playa Norte, with a Bali-style beach club and rooms with private pools. Where my parents stayed.
Check rates
Best Budget Apartment
Florida 39 rental
A chic apartment on Avenida Hidalgo with a rooftop pool, walkable to dinner and the ferry. Where I stayed.
Check rates
Best in Punta Sur
Casa de los Sueños Boutique Hotel
Stay on the quieter side of the island with stunning views and beach club access. Includes breakfast and snorkeling access.
Check rates
Best Snorkel Tour
Isla Mujeres Snorkeling Tour Adventure
Explore colorful coral reefs at three locations on this half day boat tour that ends with fresh ceviche.
Check Availability

This box contains affiliate links. I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

My verdict: stay overnight if you can

We stayed two nights, and I’m so glad we did. Staying on the island let us book a whale shark tour with an island-based operator, sleep a little later, and still be one of the first boats to find the whale sharks. We also got slow evenings in Centro and sunsets we would have missed on a day trip.

Even with two nights, I ran out of time. I wanted to dive the day after our whale shark tour, and I only rented a golf cart for two hours, so I missed spots like Isla Brewing Company and Mango Café. If I went back, I’d stay three nights.

Do a day trip if:

  • You only have a few days in Cancun.
  • You mainly want to see the island, drive the golf cart loop and spend time at Playa Norte.
  • You’re visiting outside whale shark season.

Stay overnight if:

  • You’re visiting June through September and want to swim with whale sharks.
  • You want to dive or snorkel more than once.
  • You’d rather enjoy the island in the evening, after the day-trippers leave.

Plan your Isla Mujeres trip

Want help fitting Isla Mujeres into a bigger trip, booked with points? Let’s plan it together.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *